File management on ESP32: SPIFFS and LittleFS compared

Introduction

In this article we will cover file management on ESP32. In computing, file systems are essential for organizing and managing data stored on storage devices. A file system is a structure that allows files to be stored and retrieved in an orderly manner, allowing the operating system to manage data efficiently. There are several types of file systems, each with its own characteristics and optimizations for specific use scenarios. For example, in computers, the most common file systems include NTFS (New Technology File System) used by Windows, ext4 (Fourth Extended File System) used by Linux, and HFS+ (Hierarchical File System Plus) used by macOS. These file systems support advanced features such as permission management, journaling for data protection, and management of large volumes of data.

When we move into the world of microcontrollers, like the ESP32, file management takes on an equally crucial role, but with different constraints. The ESP32, thanks to its versatility and power, is widely used in IoT and automation projects. To manage data on internal flash memory, the ESP32 uses specialized file systems such as SPIFFS (SPI Flash File System) and LittleFS. These file systems are designed to operate in resource-constrained environments, optimizing available space and data robustness.

Using a file system on the ESP32 allows you to store configurations, data logs, and other files necessary for the device to function, often eliminating the need for an SD card. However, there are situations where an SD card may be preferable, especially when larger storage capacity is required or when handling large amounts of data. Internal file systems such as SPIFFS and LittleFS are ideal for applications that require fast and reliable data management, but may not be sufficient for applications that need to store large files or perform intensive read/write operations.

In this article, we will explore SPIFFS and LittleFS in detail, comparing their features, advantages and disadvantages. In the end, you will know which file system to choose for your next project with ESP32, thus optimizing file management and improving the performance of your device.

Flash memory: brief explanation and main features

Both SPIFFS (SPI Flash File System) and LittleFS use the ESP32’s flash memory for data storage. Both file systems are designed to handle SPI flash memory, which is integrated into the ESP32 microcontroller, allowing you to store configuration files, logs, user data, and more. SPIFFS is simpler and lighter, while LittleFS offers greater robustness and more efficient management of write and erase operations, reducing the risk of data corruption and improving the lifespan of flash memory.

Flash memory is a type of non-volatile memory used for storing and transferring data in electronic devices. Here are some main features:

1. Not volatile: retains data stored even without power, making it ideal for use in embedded and consumer devices.
2. Erasable and programmable: data can be erased and rewritten, making it versatile for frequent updates.
3. Resistant: it can withstand numerous write/erase cycles, although with a specific limit that varies depending on the type of flash (NOR or NAND).
4. Compactness: high storage density in small spaces, essential for devices such as smartphones, digital cameras and microcontrollers.

Types of flash memory

• NOR Flash: fast to read, often used for execution memories.
• NAND Flash: larger capacity and writing speed, preferred for mass storage.

Use in ESP32 microcontrollers

In the context of ESP32 microcontrollers, flash memory is crucial for storing firmware, system files, and user data, making it essential to choose an efficient file system such as SPIFFS or LittleFS to effectively manage these resources.

Advantages and limitations

Advantages:

• Low energy consumption.
• High data access speed.
• Reliability and durability.

Limitations:

• Limited number of write/erase cycles.
• Complex memory management to avoid cell degradation.

Practical applications

In projects with ESP32, flash memory is used for:

• Firmware: storage of executable code.
• File System: storage of configurations, user data and logs.
• OTA Updates: allow over-the-air firmware updates without the need for additional hardware.

Choosing the right file system to manage flash memory can significantly affect the performance and reliability of your project.

Let’s now see a description of the two main ESP32 file systems: SPIFFS and LittleFS

SPIFFS (SPI Flash File System)

SPIFFS, which stands for SPI Flash File System, is a file system designed specifically for microcontrollers with flash memory. Created for resource-constrained environments, such as ESP32, SPIFFS allows you to efficiently store and manage files directly on your device’s flash memory. The maximum usable size for SPIFFS depends on the specific project configuration, but can generally range from a few kilobytes up to several megabytes, depending on the amount of flash memory available on the ESP32 device.

Main features

• Lightweight design: SPIFFS was developed to be lightweight and take up as little space as possible in the microcontroller’s memory. This makes it ideal for devices with limited storage capacity.
• Configuration file support: it is particularly suitable for storing configuration files, data logs, and other static resources that do not require frequent writing and deletion operations.
• Basic file operations: SPIFFS supports basic file operations such as reading, writing, deleting, and creating. However, it does not support nested directory management, thus limiting the complexity of the file structure.
• Memory management: handles flash memory efficiently, but can suffer from fragmentation over time due to repeated write and erase operations.
• Compatibility: it is well supported in the Arduino community, with many libraries and documentation available to simplify its implementation in projects.

Advantages

• Ease of use: SPIFFS is simple to implement and use, with an intuitive and well-documented set of APIs.
• Wide support: widely used and supported in the Arduino and ESP32 community, making it easy to troubleshoot and access resources and tutorials.
• Low memory overhead: SPIFFS uses a very compact file system structure, minimizing the memory space needed to store file and folder information.
• Dynamic wear leveling: SPIFFS automatically distributes writes to flash memory to prevent premature wear of specific areas.
• Support for files and folders: SPIFFS allows the creation, deletion, reading and writing of files and folders, just like in a traditional file system.

Disadvantages

• Lack of nested directories: does not support the creation of nested directories, limiting file organization.
• Limited robustness: less robust to crashes than other file systems like LittleFS, which can better handle data corruption.
• Lack of support for file metadata: SPIFFS does not store advanced metadata about files, such as timestamps of creation or modifications.
• Data integrity issues in the event of power outages: if there is a sudden power failure during write operations, SPIFFS may not guarantee data integrity.

Implementation example:

#include "SPIFFS.h"

void setup() {
  Serial.begin(115200);
  
  if (!SPIFFS.begin(true)) {
    Serial.println("An error has occurred while mounting SPIFFS");
    return;
  }
  
  File file = SPIFFS.open("/test.txt", FILE_WRITE);
  if (!file) {
    Serial.println("Failed to open file for writing");
    return;
  }
  file.println("Hello, SPIFFS!");
  file.close();
  
  file = SPIFFS.open("/test.txt");
  if (!file) {
    Serial.println("Failed to open file for reading");
    return;
  }
  while (file.available()) {
    Serial.write(file.read());
  }
  file.close();
}

void loop() {}

LittleFS

LittleFS is a file system designed as a more robust alternative to SPIFFS. Developed by ARM mbed, LittleFS offers more reliable data management, with advanced error handling features and support for nested directories. Like SPIFFS, LittleFS can handle variable sizes of flash memory, with capacities that can extend to several megabytes, depending on the configuration and the total space available on the ESP32 microcontroller.

Main features

• Robustness and reliability: LittleFS is designed to be resilient to crashes and data corruption. It uses a journaling system that guarantees data integrity even in the event of sudden interruptions.

Advantages

• Reliability: LittleFS offers greater protection against data corruption, making it ideal for critical applications where data loss is unacceptable.
• Support for nested directories: unlike SPIFFS, LittleFS supports the creation of nested directories, allowing for better file organization.
• Memory efficiency: manages flash memory efficiently, minimizing fragmentation and optimizing read and write operations.
• Small size: despite being robust, LittleFS maintains a small size, making it suitable for devices with limited resources.
• Support for file metadata: LittleFS stores advanced metadata about files, such as timestamps of creation or modifications, providing more complete information about files.
• Greater robustness in the event of power outages: LittleFS implements recovery mechanisms that reduce the risk of data loss in the event of sudden power failures during write operations.
• Faster reading and writing speed: LittleFS offers generally faster read and write performance than SPIFFS.

Disadvantages

• Greater complexity: can be slightly more complex to implement than SPIFFS, requiring more attention to configuration and API usage.
• Increased memory overhead: LittleFS’s file system structure requires slightly more memory space than SPIFFS.
• Less compatibility: LittleFS is a relatively new file system and may not be supported by all libraries and development tools like SPIFFS.

Implementation example:

#include "LittleFS.h"

void setup() {
  Serial.begin(115200);
  
  if (!LittleFS.begin()) {
    Serial.println("An error has occurred while mounting LittleFS");
    return;
  }
  
  File file = LittleFS.open("/test.txt", FILE_WRITE);
  if (!file) {
    Serial.println("Failed to open file for writing");
    return;
  }
  file.println("Hello, LittleFS!");
  file.close();
  
  file = LittleFS.open("/test.txt");
  if (!file) {
    Serial.println("Failed to open file for reading");
    return;
  }
  while (file.available()) {
    Serial.write(file.read());
  }
  file.close();
}

void loop() {}

Comparison of file management on ESP32 between SPIFFS and LittleFS

Below we see a table that compares the two types of ESP32 file systems:

When to use one or the other?

• When to use SPIFFS: SPIFFS is ideal for simple projects that require lightweight file management without the need for nested directories. It is perfect for storing configurations, logs and static resources.
• When to prefer LittleFS: LittleFS is recommended for more complex and critical applications where robustness and reliable data management are key. It is suitable for projects that need a more complex file structure with nested directories.

Additional considerations

• Partitioning configuration: the maximum usable size is influenced by the ESP32’s partitioning table, which must be configured to allocate sufficient space to the chosen file system.
• File system overhead: both file systems have a specific overhead that may reduce the actual space available for data.

Additional resources

• SPIFFS official documentation: Espressif SPIFFS Documentation
• LittleFS library and documentation: https://github.com/littlefs-project/littlefs

In conclusion

SPIFFS is a file system for embedded devices that uses SPI (Serial Peripheral Interface) flash memory as storage. It is designed to be simple to use and compatible with many microcontrollers, including the ESP32. This file system is particularly suitable for applications that require frequent access to data, since it does not require the use of an SD card or other type of external storage.

One of the main features of SPIFFS is its efficiency in terms of system overhead: being designed specifically for embedded devices, it minimizes the use of RAM during read/write operations. However, one disadvantage of SPIFFS compared to other file systems such as LittleFS is its vulnerability to flash memory errors. If a write error occurs on a flash memory page, SPIFFS may become unusable without manual recovery. Despite this, SPIFFS remains a popular choice for ESP32 projects due to its ease of use and its compatibility with many libraries and development tools.

LittleFS is a modern and robust file system designed specifically for embedded flash memory devices. Unlike SPIFFS, LittleFS was designed to effectively handle flash memory errors, making it more reliable in environments where operating conditions can lead to write errors. It uses a chunk-based approach to organize data, meaning that each block of data has an associated checksum to verify the integrity of the data. In the event of an error, only that block can be rewritten, reducing the risk of corruption of the entire filesystem.

LittleFS also offers a good balance between performance and security, supporting both fast reading and secure writing of data. It is designed to be easily integrated into various development environments and supports a wide range of APIs to facilitate access to files and directories. Its modular architecture allows you to add new features or adapt it to specific project needs.

An important aspect of LittleFS is its self-detection of errors, which makes it particularly useful in harsh or unstable environments. However, given these advantages, LittleFS may have a slightly higher overhead than SPIFFS, especially in terms of RAM usage during read/write operations. Despite this, for many ESP32 designs, the benefits in terms of reliability and error handling outweigh this small penalty.

Newsletter

If you want to be informed about the release of new articles, subscribe to the newsletter. Before subscribing to the newsletter read the page Privacy Policy (UE)

If you want to unsubscribe from the newsletter, click on the link that you will find in the newsletter email.

Name *

Enter your name

Email *

Enter your email

GDPR acceptance *

• You allow your email and name to be registered on this server

Send